shopping cart
nothing in cart
browse by subject
new releases
best sellers
sale books
browse by author
browse by publisher
about us
upcoming events
Oct 1st - The Tarot: Archetypal Images of Transformation [Jung Foundation of Ontario]
Oct 3rd - Creative interventions to assess and treat school refusal [SickKids CCMH Learning Institute]
Oct 3rd - Understanding and Treating Chronic Shame [Leading Edge Seminars]
Oct 3rd - Certificate in narrative therapy [SickKids CCMH Learning Institute]
Oct 6th - Dialectical behavior therapy advanced training: Formulating effective treatment plans for complex clients [SickKids CCMH Learning Institute]
schools agencies and other institutional orders (click here)
Open 9-6 Mon-Sat, 12-5 Sun. Free shipping across Canada for orders over $150. Join our mailing list! Click here to sign up.
Pathological: The True Story of Six Misdiagnoses | Hardcover
Sarah Fay
HarperCollins / Hardcover / Mar 2022
9780063068681 (ISBN-10: 0063068680)
For Those Who Prefer Hardcovers / Mad Studies
price: $34.99 (may be subject to change)
320 pages
Not in Stock, but usually ships within 2-3 weeks

“This book is a triumph of the spirit and the flesh.”—Eliza Griswold, Pulitzer Prize–winning author of Amity and Prosperity

“Masterfully written, distinctively researched, deeply humane . . . Genius.”—Anthony Swofford, author of Jarhead

“A major contribution . . . A necessary book.”—Johann Hari, author of Lost Connections

In this stunning debut—both a memoir and a work of investigative journalism that joins the ranks of works by Mary Karr, Leslie Jamison, and Joan Didion—writer Sarah Fay explores the ways we pathologize human experiences.

Over thirty years, doctors diagnosed Sarah Fay with six different mental illnesses—anorexia, major depressive disorder (MDD), anxiety disorder, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), and bipolar disorder. Pathological is the gripping story of what it was like to live with those diagnoses, and the crippling impact each had on her life. It is also a rigorous investigation into the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM)—psychiatry’s “bible,” the manual from which all mental illness diagnoses come. Like the millions of Americans who’ll receive DSM diagnoses in their lifetimes, she believed the DSM and its diagnoses were valid, only to discover that this revered manual has little scientific merit.


"An utterly unique memoir written with rare immediacy about the consequences of the language of psychiatric diagnosis. In Pathological, Fay beautifully describes navigating the uncertainty of six mental health misdiagnoses and brilliantly unpacks the dangers of labeling with a mental illness in the face of the complexities of our mental and emotional lives. Brave, heartbreaking, and inspiring, Pathological is a necessary book."
— JENN PERCY, Journalist and writer at the New York Times Magazine and recipient of the National Magazine Award for Feature Writing

"Sarah Fay has written one of the most compelling memoirs I have read in ages. Pathological is a must-read for anyone who has been through the roller coaster that is the mental illness industry in America. Fay creates a work of art that entertains as much as it informs; if this were a movie, it would be the sort of documentary that contains every mode from romantic comedy to art-house film to thriller in one. The prose is so electric, incisive, witty, irreverent, devastating, sparkling! Whether she is riffing on the mechanics of English grammar, confronting the DSM in full-on unapologetic manifesto-mode, or winding us through the ups and downs of a very fully-lived life, Sarah Fay has created a masterpiece that is a true original on every level."
— POROCHISTA KHAKPOUR, author of Sick: A Memoir

"Pathological is the best book I've read in many years. Masterfully written, distinctively researched, and deeply humane, it joins our finest literature on medicine and psychiatry and the eternal riddle we call our minds. Fay’s artful work is pleasingly unclassifiable: call it medical memoir; mental health thriller; comic punctuation primer; DSM and Big Pharma smackdown. I’ll just call it genius. It’s also contrarian, controversial, and beautifully, validly angry. If you or anyone you love has spent time in the mental health industrial complex (or, cauldron)—buy this book now and read it."
— ANTHONY SWOFFORD, International and New York Times bestselling author of Jarhead

“In this brilliant and excruciating memoir, through careful reporting and exquisite analysis, Fay takes on the myriad ways in which women's minds, not simply our bodies, have become a marketplace for trendy and dangerous ideas about mental health. This book is a triumph of the spirit and the flesh for a woman who since the age of twelve has been fighting, against all odds, not only to survive, but to live.”
— ELIZA GRISWOLD, Pulitzer Prize-winning author of Amity & Prosperity

"We urgently need to think about our mental and emotional pain and distress in a more loving, nuanced, and intelligent way. Pathological will be a major contribution towards achieving that - a crucial and necessary book.”
— JOHANN HARI, New York Times bestselling author of Lost Connections: Why You're Depressed and How to Find Hope

"Sharply personal and impeccably detailed, (Pathological) is bound to raise questions in the minds of readers diagnosed with any number of disorders about the validity of trying to cram individual experience into what Fay contends are essentially imaginary categories. A provocative and original examination of the flaws in mental health treatment."
Kirkus Reviews (starred review)

About the Author:

Sarah Fay is an author and activist. Her writing appears in many publications, including Longreads, The New York Times, The Atlantic, Time Magazine, The New Republic, McSweeney’s, The Believer, and The Paris Review, where she served as an advisory editor. She’s the recipient of the Hopwood Award for Literature, as well as grants and fellowships from Yaddo, the Mellon Foundation, and the MacDowell Colony, among others. She’s the founder of Pathological: The Movement (, a public awareness campaign devoted to making people aware of the unreliability and invalidity of DSM diagnoses and the dangers of identifying with an unproven mental illness. For more, visit

Caversham Booksellers
98 Harbord St, Toronto, ON M5S 1G6 Canada
(click for map and directions)
All prices in $cdn
Copyright 2022

Phone toll-free (800) 361-6120
Tel (416) 944-0962 | Fax (416) 944-0963
E-mail [email protected]
Hours: 9-6 Mon-Sat / Sunday 12-5 (EST)

Click here to read previous issues.
other lists
For Those Who Prefer Hardcovers
HarperCollins Publishers
Mad Studies
October 2022 New Arrivals